Andean Flamingos, Chile

Andean Flamingos, Chile
See post on flamingos, rheas and camelids

Tuesday, November 22, 2016

Invasive Lobsters To The Vancouver Sun, August 7, 2016: If the Hon. Dominic LeBlanc’s bureaucrats and negotiators think that “scientific evidence is far from certain” that American lobsters pose no threat to European lobsters, then they haven’t sought or listened to scientific advice. American lobsters do not occur naturally in Europe and would be a dangerous invasive, alien, exotic species. The two are different species, but can interbreed. The world is full of ecological disasters caused by introduction of exotic species, but we have only to look at British Columbia to see the dangers. These examples are only three of many: exotic milfoil fowling Okanagan Lake, alien knapweeds ruining cattle pastures throughout our interior grasslands and introduced mysid shrimp destroying trout fisheries in Kootenay and Arrow Lakes. No credible scientist would recommend any trade actions that could result in introducing our species into their waters.
Re: What Happens After Mosul: After ISIL is Defeated, Kurdish Forces May Push for Independent Territory, by Matthew Fisher October 18, 2016 to The Vancouver Sun: So what if the Kurds seek independence? The Kurds are the only good guys in this whole cruel, chaotic catastrophe. Saddam Hussein gassed them by the thousands, back when there really were weapons of mass destruction. Yet beyond organizing an effective, semi-autonomous administration of their own territory in northern Iraq in the postwar governance vaccuum, they have never said, or in actions suggested, that they sought territorial expansion or subjugation of others. Their Peshmerga fighters have been the only effective military force on the ground in the region and they have only fought for defense of their land, and to help others under attack by the jihadis. In 2014, when ISIL massacred whole villages of Yasidis except for the young women whom they sold into sex slavery, who came to the aid of survivors clustering on a remote mountain? Not Canada, politically afraid to put “boots on the ground”. Not Iraqi forces, who ran away. Not the USA or the UK, although they dropped supplies from aircrafft. Only the Peshmerga came to save the Yasidis. In Turkey, no doubt the PKK have committed atrocities, but far fewer than the government of Turkey has committed against them in a brutal, sustained campaign of intimidation. But Turkish Kurds have elected members to Turkey’s parlimant, participating in such democracy as is available to them. In Syria, Peshmerga fighters have liberated Kurdish villages from ISIS, but have refused to be drawn into the wider conflicts. Yes, Kurds have been accused of driving Arabs out of their territory in Iraq, but their side of this story is that these were “foreigners” whom Saddam Hussein had forcibly settled in Kurdish territory. Arming Kurds can only serve humanitarian goals in the short term. In the long term it is unlikely to lead to calls for sovereignty, but even if it does, it would solve more problems than it creates. What is wrong with self-determination for a people with their own language and culture who are abused by every country that their ancestral homeland covers?
From August 4, 2015 to The Vancouver Sun: Daphne Braham (Compassionate Canada has lots its way) is right: this is no longer the Canada we love and thought we knew. In 1970 I left a country (USA) that was conflicted internally and going around the world deposing democratically elected presidents and installing dictators. I chose Canada, tranquil internally and known as a neutral peacemaker internationally. I drove to the border and presented my credentials. Immigrants needed 50 points: so many points for a university education (check), so many for a job offer (I was going to a $200/month plus room and board job), so many for being married (the marriage was over, but I still had the license), cash (I had about $200, just enough to prove I wasn’t indigent), and so on. In an hour I was a Landed Immigrant, and in five years, a Citizen. How different now, when people arriving at the border, just like I did, are thrown in jail by the boatload, and immigration has declined to a trickle, even as the need escalates exponentially! Braham quotes former Senator Pat Carney writing to Immigration Minister Chris Alexander suggesting that we “bring in 100,000 of them [Syrian refugees] to Canada immediately,” of the 4,088,078 registered by the United Nations. Canada is a big land with few people and lots of resources. From 2002 to 2006 I worked in the Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan assessing the impact of 1.4 million refugees that had fled Kuwait in 1990 when Iraq invaded. They came to a country, about the size of British Columbia, with virtually no natural resources, that was still struggling to integrate an influx of about 2.1 million Palestinian refugees after the 1967 and 1973 wars. During 2003, I watched droves of Iraqis fleeing the war debark from the Baghdad–Amman busses, adding another 200,000 to Jordan’s stressed population. By August 2014, some 608,000 Syrian had crossed into Jordan. Their main refugee camp near Mafraq was a pastoral paradise when I saw it last in 2006, shepherds grazing their goats, sheep and camels in a sea of grass. If tiny Jordan, bereft of natural resources, can take in so many millions of desperate people, how can Canada not follow Carney’s advice and accept at least 100,000 immediately, as a first start?

Friday, February 8, 2013

Tuaregs in the Sahara

In our headlong rush to drive Islamic jihadists out of Mali and Algeria, Canada and its allies should take care to distinguish between al Qaida-linked militants and the largely peaceful (if sometimes rebellious), native Tuareg nomads. Tuaregs have legitimate grievances. From the early Islamic period on, they operated vast caravan networks across the Sahara. Besides commodities such salt and silver (Tuaregs are renowned for their silver craftsmanship), they traded books. Wealthy trade centres such as Timbuktu became centres of scholarship. The 600 year-old university there was capable of housing 25,000 students and had one of the largest libraries in the world with half a million or more manuscripts. Today the university, mosques and private collections still hold a treasure trove of ancient knowledge and history, earning UNESCO designation as a World Heritage Site. The colonial powers in the 19th and early 20th Centuries developed farming communities in the Sahel, the broad grassland that runs right across Africa south of the Sahara. They brought black slaves and serfs from further south northward to farm, depriving the Tuareg and other Saharan/Sahelian nomad peoples of their dry-season foraging areas. After the Colonial period, the traditional Tuareg homeland was divided among half a dozen modern nations. In the 1960s, misguided international aid agencies drilled wells and further encouraged “sedentarization” of the nomads, resulting in overgrazing around natural oases and water developments. Resulting desertification disrupted the pastoral patterns and caused large-scale loss of wildlife habitat—this is why big game animals such as addax, oryx, gazelles, ibex and Barbary sheep, which were a key part of Tuareg culture, have disappeared. Loss of forage for livestock resulted in repeated famines in various parts of the Sahel since 1968. The famines of 1973–1975 and 1984 were especially severe and burned into our minds the plight of starving people in Ethiopia, Eritrea, Sudan, Biafra (now returned to Nigeria) and other Sahelian countries. Climate change that began to be felt in the 1980s, first identified by Canadian wildlife biologists A. R. E. Sinclair and J. M. Fryxell in a 1985 journal article, made it worse. The human tragedies were caused not by lack of rainfall, but by massive starvation of livestock because of overgrazing. Tuaregs resisted French colonial invasion of their homelands in the late 19th Century and some have been rebelling off and on in various Northern African countries ever since. But many just want to make a living and keep their culture. Although largely prevented from migrating south in the dry season, they still bring their livestock north to the mountains of Morocco, where their camps and flocks of sheep, goats and camels, sometimes numbering more than 1,000 animals, are a colourful part of the scenery. The markets in towns all along the northern edge of the Sahara are enlivened with Tuareg nomads selling beautiful handicrafts. For a modern view of Tuaregs, read “In Search of Nomads” by John Ure,” 2003. The nomads are not the aggressors in the current crisis, but victims. If anyone doubts this, just recall only months ago when foreign jihadists took overran Timbuktu. In an echo of the Taliban destruction of the giant Buddha sculptures at Bamiyan, Afghanistan, in 2001, al Qaida-linked militants began destroying ancient monuments in Timbuktu that the Tuareg people had proudly maintained for centuries. This is not to say that Tuareg individuals or groups have not joined the Islamists’ militancy; or vice- versa for pragmatic reasons on both sides. But Islamists need Tuaregs (for their camel transport and desert refuges) more than Tuaregs need Islamists. Nomadic cultures, a crucial step in human evolution and a unique component of modern cultural diversity, are disappearing everywhere that they occur because of their inherent conflict with expanding settlements and development. If Western governments and our African allies treat Tuaregs sensitively, there is an opportunity to separate the Islamists from their local support while addressing long-standing governance issues.

British Columbia Carbon Credits

From 24 March 2012: “Carbon credits! Honey, we can make millions! All we have to do is refrain from logging around the cabin. The government will give us money.” “That’s crazy.” “No, it’s a government program. Our 17 acres covered with trees...that’s a lot of carbon dioxide getting sucked out of the atmosphere.” “They’re just little trees. They won’t be big enough to log for two hundred years.” “Doesn’t matter. Trees are trees. Each one could make a 2 x 4, at least. Anyway, no one is measuring them. ” “But the first eight years we owned the property, we did nothing but burn logging slash left by the previous owners. Didn’t that emit carbon dioxide?” “That was ‘site preparation.’ Remember those 100 Douglas-fir seedlings we planted? Reforestation! More carbon credits.” “That was 1992. The carbon credit law was only passed in 2007.” “That’s the beauty of it: it’s retroactive!” “Yeah, but they’re still baby trees. What about all the grown-up trees we cut for building logs?” “Right! Those logs are still there, sequestering away. Four sides, 10 logs high: 40 trees. At a cubic meter of carbon dioxide per tree, that’s 40 cubic meters per year of carbon dioxide we’re sequestering...every year!” “...and the trees we cut for firewood every year? That pours carbon dioxide up the chimney?” “It stops us from using coal! More carbon credits! We’ll make a fortune!" “That’s crazy.” “Honey, it’s saving the planet. And it’s the law here in BC.”

Destruction of Aleppo

From 5 August 2012: Even knowing that it is unconscionably tacky to bemoan a personal loss when people are fighting and dying in the streets, the battle for Aleppo hurts me personally. It is yet another of the world’s most exciting places I’ll never see because it is being ruined by war. In all the commentary in the news media lately, not a single report that I have read has mentioned the ancient, historic souq, or market, of old Aleppo. It is the largest covered market in the world, with an approximate length of 13 kilometers and labyrinthine alleyways, many covered by ancient stone arches, adding to a total length of 32 kilometers. At 50 centuries, it is the world’s oldest. A souq in any language is the soul of a country. Tourists flock to Istanbul to see its famous, ancient spice market, which would fit into a small corner of Aleppo’s souq. I have never been to Aleppo. While working in Jordan 10 years ago, I read an article about the souq of Aleppo in the Jordanian Times and resolved to see it sometime. Alas, with the Syrian rebels digging into the old city and battling the government with captured tanks while government jets and helicopters bombard it, I fear there may not be much left to see when the fighting stops. Aleppo’s souq is the latest in a long line of the world’s most valuable cultural heritage sites ruined by war. The first on my personal wish list to fall was the Khyber Pass between Afghanistan and Pakistan. I read about it in 1962 in a short story by Dorothy Gilman Butters in the Ladies Home Journal, “Sorrow rides a fast horse.” In it, a mother, grief-stricken from the death of her husband, takes her two children on a whirl-wind trip around the world. In the Khyber Pass, her family and their elderly guide are captured by bandits. Their leader speaks to the guide, who translates. “Are they going to capture us?” she asks anxiously. “They already have, “says the guide. They don't want just the money, the food, and the donkeys. They want the woman and the children. The guide says sadly, “It must by your qismat—your fate—to stop here.” She says harshly, “My qismat? Tell this man I must travel like the wind—that is my qismat. Tell him that Sorrow rides behind me on a fast horse—if he listens closely, he may hear the hoof beats. Tell him that if he captures me, he will capture Sorrow as well—because where I go Sorrow goes and where I stop, Sorrow will stop.” The bandits confer. Their leader finally makes a statement. The guide translates: “He says it has been a hard year, with many people dead in their village. Sheep have sickened and died. He says they do not wish for more Sorrow. If Sorrow follows behind you then you must leave these mountains at once. You must not stop even to sleep.” To ensure their prompt departure, the bandits guide them through the Khyber Pass. After reading this story at age 15, I wanted to see the Khyber Pass for myself. Sadly, I waited too long and Sorrow returned. Traders on the Silk Road traversed it. Darius the Great, King of Persia from 522 to 486 BC, took his army through it. So did Alexander the Great in 326 BC. In 1220 Genghis Khan led his Mongol army through it to conquer Arabia. Britain fought three wars over it from 1839 to 1919. Rudyard Kipling immortalized it in “Ballad of the King’s Jest”: “When spring-time flushes the desert grass, Our kafilas wind through the Khyber Pass. Lean are the camels but fat the frails, Light are the purses but heavy the bales, As the snowbound trade of the North comes down To the market-square of Peshawur town.” Kipling set the one of the central events in his book, Kim, in the Khyber Pass and called it “a sword cut through the mountains.” The book describes “the great game,” the cold war between Britain and Russia for imperial hegemony in Afghanistan. Winston Churchill, then a young newspaper correspondent, in 1897 said of the Khyber Pass, “Each rock and hill along the pass had a story to tell! “ In December, 1979, when Russia seized Afghanistan, one of their invasion routes was eastward from Kabul through the Khyber Pass. In the 1980s, the mujahedeen used it to attack the Russians. In 2001, the USA used it to attack the Taliban. The world was outraged when the Taliban destroyed the monumental statues of the Buddha at Bamiyan, but hardly murmured when the Baghdad Archaeological Museum was left unprotected by invading American forces two years later. That museum, founded by Gertrude Bell nearly a century ago, was another on my list. Bell was a British adventurer and archaeologist who in 1913 defied Ottoman authorities in Damascus, bought some camels, hired a guide, and marched into the desert in search of rumoured wonders of the ancient world. Mapping and cataloguing ancient ruins, along the way she met and befriended the Shaykhs of the major Bedouin tribes in the Arabian Peninsula. She escaped Turkish authorities near what is now Amman, Jordan, and was jailed in Ha’il, in what is now Saudi Arabia, by the Emir Muhammad al Rashid. Her writings opened up the Arabian deserts to the world, and her knowledge of the Bedouin tribes made her a valuable mentor to C. E. Lawrence (“of Arabia”, who was no scholar and just in it for the glory) and advisor to Winston Churchill and the other Western leaders in the First World War and its aftermath. It was she who actually put pen to paper and drew the boundaries of the new nations of Syria, Jordan, Iraq, and Saudi Arabia. Her friendship with King Faisal facilitated founding of the Baghdad Archaeological Museum, using her own collection as a start. For nearly a century it was the best in the world for Middle East history and prehistory. Now the museum, like the artifacts it once housed, is a relic. Another place I always wanted to see was Timbuktu, in what is now Mali. Although its very name evokes, in Western culture, one of the most remote places on the planet, it was, since the 12th Century, a center of Arab scholarship. It hosts an Islamic university and houses tens of thousands of priceless manuscripts from a time when Europe had hardly emerged from the Dark Ages. In April of this year it was overrun by Tuareg rebels, and just weeks ago, in July, Islamists began destroying ancient tombs of Muslim saints. Timbuktu no doubt will still be worth visiting when peace returns, but it won’t be the same. This has happened so often in my life that I feel as if the culture of my species is being bled dry. When the Japanese occupied Korea in the Second World War, they destroyed and stole much of the country’s ancient heritage; and during the Cultural Revolution in China, zealots destroyed countless thousands of Buddhist temples. I’ve seen some in both countries that were later rebuilt, but there is a sadness in seeing only modern reconstructions. Each time, we all lose something precious. It is the cultural equivalent of the ancient Chinese torture, “death by a thousand cuts.” As a child, I read about the splendour of the ancient monuments at Angkor Wat, an ancient Khmer kingdom in Cambodia. The Khmer Rouge, for all their other failings, protected it, but after their fall in 1979, in the governance vacuum, an industrial-scale army of thieves stripped most of its beautiful carvings and statues. I finally did see Angkor Wat, but the missing statues and art, crudely hacked from the stones, were so depressing that I almost wish I hadn’t. In the 18th through early 20th Centuries, European and North African wars were led by aristocrats, and these educated gentlemen went to great lengths to avoid destroying the cultural heritage of their enemies, realizing that war is transitory and heritage is forever. I doubt that the military officer training at Sandhurst,Saint-Cyr, West Lincoln, Dresden, Anapolis and West Point covers these subjects in much detail. All war is wrong, but war that targets cultural heritage is especially heinous. It is time to re-introduce a more sensitive tone to military campaigns in all venues possible (such as international treaties and officer training) and elevate the level of cultural crimes in international courts to crimes against humanity. ___________________

Wednesday, July 25, 2012

Conservative government destroys good science

On June 7, 2012, I maile the following letter to Mr. Ashfield with copies to the Prime Minister Stephen Harper and Minister Kent: The Hon. Keith Ashfield, Minister of Fisheries and Oceans House of Commons Ottawa, Ontario K1A 0A6 Dear Mr. Ashfield: Not being a fisheries or aquatic biologist, you might think my colleagues and I would have scant knowledge of or interest in the Experimental Lakes. Not so. In my career, as a biologist, section head and division manager with Environment Canada, I have had many times to hire biologists with fisheries, aquatic biology, or limnology training. The first thing I looked at on their applications was whether they had Experimental Lakes experience during university. That was the way to know that they had both superior training by Canada’s elite science faculty, and real-world experience. I could depend on these young scientists to recognize a Daphnia when they saw one, to know a hypo- from a hyperlimnion, and to fix an outboard motor when it konked on the way home from a survey. Even if their jobs had nothing to do with aquatic biology, I knew that these were the best people to serve Environment Canada, and the country. The Experimental Lakes sites and program have produced generations of Canada’s top scientists and were the foundation for innumerable masters’ and PhD theses and scientific publications by scholars from all over the world. Students and scientists working there discovered the effects of phosphorus in detergents and acid rain, allowing my former Department to eliminate these scourges of lake ecosystems. It is the best and longest running lake biology experiment in the world—there is nothing else like it. It would be short-sighted indeed to cancel funding for it. Sincerely, Lee Harding, PhD cc: The Hon. Stephen Harper, Prime Minister The Hon. Peter Kent, Minister of the Environment

Canada guts environmental legislation

I mailed this letter to Mr. Harper on June 7 with copies to Ministers Ashfield and Kent. June 7, 2012 The Hon. Stephen Harper, Prime Minister House of Commons Ottawa, Ontario K1A 0A6 Dear Mr. Harper: RE: BILL C-38 Have you any idea how badly the changes to the Fisheries Act, the Canadian Environmental Assessment Act, and the other changes to environmental legislation, will affect my business? My company and the hundreds of other environmental consulting firms in Canada will have hardly any work if these changes proceed. Developers will have no need to hire biologists to see that their projects are designed to mitigate environmental impacts. Of course, I would gladly suffer lost clients and business if the environment would still be protected, but it will not. You are well aware of the inter-linkages of environmental legislation: • The Fisheries Act is a “trigger” the invokes the Canadian Environmental Assessment Act • When invoked, the Canadian Environmental Assessment Act ensures consideration of all components of the environment, including archaeological sites and other cultural heritage values. • Protecting fish also protects water- and riparian-associated wildlife and endangered species. I started working in this business in 1972, before there was even an environmental impact assessment policy, let alone an Act. I spent most of my career with Environment Canada and have two awards from that Department for meritorious service and a letter of congratulations upon my retirement signed by one of your Prime Minister predecessors. No one thinks these Acts can’t use a little tweaking to improve fairness and efficiency; but this is too much. Please stop it. Sincerely, Lee E. Harding, PhD, RPBio President, owner and Chief Scientist cc: The Hon. Keith Ashfield, Minister of Fisheries and Oceans The Hon. Peter Kent, Minister of the Environment

Tuesday, February 28, 2012

Ottawa to keep records on Canadians' border crossings for the American government

Published in the Globe and Mail, December 2011:
Re: "How Ottawa will track who’s coming, who’s going and where” December 8, 2011, p. A10:

So, Ottawa will keep a record of every time I drive to Oregon to visit my Mom or my plane stops in Texas on the way to a business meeting in South America, but cancelled the long-form census and doesn’t want to know if I own a rifle?


Background: the Conservative government cancelled the mandatory long-form census in 2011, and the long-gun (i.e., rifles and shotguns) registry, a key part of Canada's gun law,in February 2012.

Coquitlam endorses pesticide bay bylaw

Published in the Coquitlam Now, February 24, 2012

Councillor O’Neill grossly distorts the precautionary principle and disingenuously ignores the huge body of scientific knowledge of cosmetic pesticides. The precautionary principle guides us to avoid chemicals that are known to be dangerous without waiting for overwhelming proof that they sicken people and pets in our own city, or in our yards. The toxicity of these chemicals is known in minute detail; as a former Environment Canada toxicologist, I have produced some of the literature myself. While modern pesticides are not as toxic or persistent as older, banned ones, they are still toxic or they would not work. Used as directed, they still kill beneficial, non-target organisms, such as earthworms. The Health Canada approvals only apply when used as prescribed, but many people use too much, or too often, or to kill plants or animals not prescribed on the labels. Pesticides can drift into a neighbour’s yard, or be tracked into the house by pets and people. Some people and pets are more sensitive than average, and can become sick even when a pesticide is used as directed. There are cheap and easy alternatives, such as a weed puller for dandelions and non-pesticide treatments for fungus on the roses or weevils on the rhododendrons. We should keep cosmetic chemicals out of our city because we don’t need them for healthy yards and gardens and because however benign they are, they still kill.

Sandhills, Bison, Pronghorns and Pipelines



In expressing angst about attacks on the proposed Keystone pipeline (Pipeline Shutdown, Nathan Vanderlippe and Carrie Tait, Globe and Mail, November 11, 2011, p. B1), could you not at least mention the environmental values that it threatens? Maybe even run a photo of it, instead of protesters in Washington? The Nebraska Sandhills are an iconic landscape “where the buffalo roam, where the deer and the antelope play”, and a unique ecozone. In 2010, I had a chance to visit the Sandhills for the first time. My brother and I parked the car many times and just walked out across the prairie. We watched hawks hunt prairie dogs under a sky that went on forever, saw pronghorn antelope gather at a waterhole, and were unnerved by a glowering bison bull moving between his herd and us. There is nowhere else on Earth where one can see this wildlife community in an undisturbed, natural environment. It is worth protecting.

Doing business with undemocratic regimes

Geoffrey York wrote in The high cost of doing business with undemocratic regimes (Folio, Globe and Mail, March 21, 2011) what a great many Canadians have been saying privately for a long time. The Democratic Republic of Congo, where Human Rights Watch estimated in 2009 that 200,000 women and girls had been raped since 1998, as Mr. York stated, is Canada’s top African investment portfolio at $3.34 billion. Putting retirement savings into ethical business funds as my wife and I do is only part of the solution. Canada should introduce regulations to make sure that our companies do not engage in practices abroad that would be illegal here, and compel them to disclose tax and revenue paid to foreign governments , as the USA has done in the recently-passed Dodd-Frank bill.

The spiralling food security crisis

“The spiralling food security crisis” (Celebrities raise awareness of world agricultural crisis” Jessica Leeder, Globe and Mail, March 16, 2011) may be puzzling policy-makers and governments, but not researchers. Sixteen years have passed since Lester Brown, an agricultural economist, published “Who will feed China?” In it, he showed that agricultural production could not rise in the future nearly as much as it had in the previous 50 years because the easy gains from irrigation and mass production of fertilizer had already been realized, there is no more good agricultural land, and no more water. He showed that fish production in the world’s oceans had peaked at about 100 millions tonnes. And he predicted that, with global food production nearly stagnating and population continuing to rise exponentially, the per capita food production would surely decline.

These predictions have come true. The wild seafood supply per person peaked at 17 kg in 1988 and now stands at 14 kg. The amount of cropland per person in 1950 was 0.23 ha, but in 2007 was 0.10 ha. Fish and shellfish farms have partially offset some of the losses in wild ocean fish production, but at tremendous cost to coastal fisheries and agriculture. Corn and soy crops have increased in Brazil, but at tremendous cost to tropical forest ecosystems and biodiversity. Moreover, much of the increased production is going to feed cars (via ethanol) instead of hungry people. Meanwhile, in 2007 people in 22 countries from Bangladesh to Yemen rioted in the streets because of food price increases. Since 2004, governments of five African countries of re-allocated (sold outright or leased in long-term contracts) 2,492,684 ha of land (excluding allocations below 1000 ha) away from smallholders to big business, many of them foreign. They include governments or businesses in Saudi Arabia, Yemen, Kuwait, Qatar, India, Britain, South Korea, and China. The rate of farmland reallocation to foreigners increased dramatically after the 2007–2008 food crisis as countries seek to increase their own food security. The government of Madagascar fell in 2009 because of a popular uprising against the government’s 99 year leases of almost 1.8 million ha of farmland to South Korean and Indian companies. The 2011 riots that started “Arab Spring” were but a continuation of this crisis, the roots of which are (a) global population increases, and (b) the failure of developed countries including Canada to focus international policies where it matters: in the stomachs of poor people.

Mammoths live until 3700 years ago

This doesn’t take anything away from “Lost Giants” (Charles Q. Choi, Scientific American, Feburary 2010, p. 21) but megafauna persisted well after 13,700 years ago. In Europe, the dramatic contraction in mammoth range occurred about 12,000 years ago. A mastodon at the Manis Site in Washington was dated to 12,000-11,000 years, and drarf mammoths have been dated to about 3,700 years ago on Wrangel Island, Siberia, and to 7,900 years ago on St. Paul Island, Alaska. The Manis mastodon had a stone point embedded in a rib.

Monday, February 13, 2012

Momentum builds to ban shark fin soup, but is needed for other species, too

News reports show that an increasing number of restaurants are taking shark fin soup off the menu and many cities in Asia and North America are banning the import of shark fins, or from servince soup made from them. In Canada, a Member of Parliament is preparing to table a bill for legislation to make shark fin soup illegal in Canada. This is because of the inhumane nature of the "finning" (in which fins are cut from live sharks, which are then returned to the sea to die agonizingly and slowly); and because the practice, and the culinary tradition that encourages it, is driving many species of shark toward extinction. The soup is mainly for Chinese markets in China and in Chinese communities elsewhere, to whom shark fin soup is considered a delicacy, not only for its flavour, but because anything exotic or rare is highly valued in Chinese cuisine and that of southeast Asian countries, such as Vietnam.

It is not just sharks that are endangered by Chinese and other southeast Asian peoples’ predilection for exotic foods and medicines. A Vietnamese rhinoceros (a subspecies of Javan rhino) is probably extinct because of this, according to a 2011 report; Vietnam, besides having its own flourishing endangered species food/medicine industry, is a major conduit for trafficking endangered species into China. Vietnamese smugglers and Chinese traders are behind the current (since 2008) upswing in African rhinoceros poaching, both black and white rhinoceros species. Since 2008, some 2000 (at least) white rhinos and many of the more endangered black rhinos have been poached from Kruger National Park, South Africa, for example, and one was even killed for its horn in tiny Swaziland. England has seen several dozen museum specimens of mounted rhinoceros heads stolen from their glass display cages this year.

I’ve been studying and writing a series of scientific journal papers on southeast Asian primates, and every one I have written about is either endangered or critically imperilled, i.e., on the verge extinction.

Here is one of many ironies: a species of gibbon (a hominoid ape, like us) on Hainan Island, China, is down to perhaps fewer than 20 individuals left in the world, and until last year was listed as one of the 25 most endangered primates in the world (a report prepared every five years by the IUCN and WWF). But in 2010, a few score of individuals of another species in the same genus were discovered hanging on (ahem! –gibbons are brachiators) in the mountains along the Vietnam-China border. This species had been thought extinct for the last 100 years, so the Hainan Black Gibbon was removed from the 25-most-endangered list to make room for the rediscovered Eastern Black Gibbon. How can a species of primate with fewer than two score left in the world not be on the list of the world’s most endangered primates?

The species that I most recently studied, the White-cheeked Gibbon (see reference below), is extirpated from China, nearly extirpated from Vietnam where only 100 or so remain, and down to a few hundred individuals in Laos. A species of monkey that I published a paper on last year, endemic to Vietnam, is down to fewer than 200 individuals in three heavily-fragmented populations, two of which will surely go extinct in the next year or two. These rare species of primates are illegally trapped in every national park in which they still occur (none occur outside of parks), and most are traded into China. Even endangered primates (orangutans, for example) from as far away as Borneo are poached and traded into China.

It would be interesting to take a forensic look at the exotic “medicines” for sale in Vancouver’s Chinatown, to see what endangered species might turn up there.

Papers cited:

Harding, LE. 2012. Nomascus leucogenys. Mammalian Species 44(890):1–15

Harding, LE. 2011. Trachypithecus delacouri. Mammalian Species 43(880):118-128

Harding, L.E. 2011. Rare Mammals Recorded in Borneo, Malaysia. Taprobanica 3(2):107–109

Harding, L.E. 2011. Unusual Affiliative Behaviour in Orangutans. Taprobanica 3(2):110–111

Harding, L.E. 2011. Red morph of silvered lutung (Trachypithecus cristatus) rediscovered in Borneo, Malaysia. Taprobanica 3(1): 47-48

Harding, LE. 2010. Trachypithecus cristatus. Mammalian Species. 42(862):149–165

Alien Trout in British Columbia

No one complains about having ring-necked pheasants or California quail around, and few mind seeing introduced Rocky Mountain Bighorn Sheep in the range of native California Bighorn Sheep, but sometimes the introduction of exotic species has unintended consequences. They can prey on, compete with or parasitize native species; contaminate their genome by hybridizing; and spread diseases to which native species have no immunity. Ecological catastrophes due to invasive aliens are legendary: Indian mongoose (Herpestes auropunctatus), rats (Rattus spp.) and cane toads (Bufo marinus) in Hawaii, European rabbits (Oryctolagus cuniculus) in Argentina and Australia, and so on. Of the 18 exotic fish province-wide, 16 (37% of all fish species) occur in the Columbia River basin. This is a higher proportion of introduced species than in any other river system in British Columbia. They include eastern brook trout (Salvelinus fontinalis), brown trout (Salmo trutta), lake trout (Salvelinus namaycush), broad whitefish (Coregonus nasus), carp (Cyprinus carpio), goldfish (Carassius auratus), tench (Tinca tinca), brown catfish (bullhead: Ictalurus nebulosus), black catfish (bullhead: Ictalurus melas), pumpkin seed (Lepomis gibbosus), black crappie (Pomoxis nigromaculatus), largemouth bass (Micropterus salmoides), smallmouth bass (Micropterus dolomieui), yellow perch (Perca flavescens) and walleye (Stizostedion vitreum). Most introductions in British Columbia have been accidental, but a distressingly high number were purposeful. For example, the introductions of Gerrard rainbow trout into upper Arrow Lake has combined with the exotic mysids and nutrient starvation as well as migration blockage to virtually (possibly completely) exterminate the yellowfin rainbow. Eastern brook trout have invaded and displaced native trout, including the endangered westslope cutthroat trout. Widespread stocking of non-native stocks of rainbow trout has displaced no one knows how many native rainbow trout stocks, and has polluted the westslope cutthroat trout genome by introgressive hybridization. At best, exotic species change biological communities and endangers native species. At worst, they can endanger whole ecosystems.

Infant-carrying and bipedalism in humans

Way back at least to H. erectus times, pair bonding and neoteny meant that both parents were needed to care for infants. And they had to travel with them: at least one infant or toddler (interbirth interval may have been longer, like in bush-living !Kung, 4 years, instead of developed-world humans, less than 2 years) and another one or two dependent juveniles. They travelled widely, all the way to Java and China (well, strictly speaking, the population expanded that far, but individuals must have travelled widely for that to happen). They had to cross rough terrain, like canyons, and wade innumerable creeks and streams (how they got across big rivers like the Indus, Ganges and Irrawaddy is another question). So the mother carries the infant or toddler, and the man does what? Go to any urban park and you’ll see: human males universally carry toddlers on their shoulders, leaving one hand free to lead a pre-adolescent. We need a strong vertebral column for this, and a very upright posture. You must have noticed that when carrying anything heavy, your back could support way more weight than your arms, and the weight forced you to walk very erect. Humans are so programmed to carry heavy weights on our backs that we go backpacking for fun. I think the human vertebral column is way stronger than needed for ordinary and infrequent carrying, like meat back from a hunt. We had to be carrying toddlers. I’ve even been tempted to wonder the sexually dimorphic width and strength of men’s shoulder girdles might have been involved in toddler-carrying. Women can’t carry kids on their shoulders, which are too narrow, for any length of time—the kids slip off.

Sunday, October 9, 2011

Homo erectus crossed the Indus, Ganges, and Irrawaddy



An interesting news item (Zach Zorich, Palaeolithic Tools, Archaeology, January/February 2011), but why the surprise that H. erectus/ergaster could cross 40 miles of open sea to reach Crete?

When I was little, my family often went camping and many times my brother and I made use of a drift log to reach islands out in a lake, or to cross a river. As a young field biologist working in remote wilderness in northern Canada, we often lashed a few logs together to make a raft to cross rivers; the photo is an example. It seems obvious that Homo erectus , who clearly had the tool-using skills, would have done so.

Much earlier than the Crete crossing, H. erectus evidently crossed Mab el Mandeb at the mouth of the Red Sea (although it was probably narrower then), and reached the islands of Java and Sumatra (but the Sunda Shelf may have been exposed). Regardless of these uncertain sea crossings, they must have also crossed the Indus, Ganges, and Irrawaddy Rivers to reach Java, and the Mekong River to reach China, in addition to countless smaller, though still daunting, rivers. These crossings imply technology for river/sea transport, not only of people (including infants and toddlers who could hardly have straddled a floating log, for example) but also of tools and supplies.

Crossing to Crete is another matter: 40 miles is a long way. But I feel certain that if any homonids from H. erectus on could see land across the water, they could reach it.

Saturday, October 1, 2011

China's and Burma's Forests and Canadian Forest Investments



The white-handed gibbon is extinct in China and this is one of the reasons why:

Since cutting natural forest has been illegal in China since 1998 (the Natural Forest Protection Ban), the country has embarked on a massive aforestation program. This is where the alleged Yunnan timber holdings of a certain Canadian-Chinese investment company come in. But “...the allocation of land for economic land concessions (including plantations) often raises questions about how local communities have been engaged, processes for free and prior informed consent, and long-term benefits for these communities.” EU Baseline Study 1, China: Overview of forest governance, markets and Trade. European Union, June 2011). Seems like a poor, or at least unethical, basis for investment to me.

China only produces about 70 m3/year from a forest base of some 8% of the country, and most of its domestic production now is from plantations of poplar, Chinese fir and Masson pine, mainly for plywood and paper. For furniture wood and lumber, it needs to import wood. The above-mentioned EU report discretely notes, “several of the countries which are major suppliers to China’s forest products industry ...[provide] illegally sourced wood materials” and “documentation of source of origin at district levels of Chinese timber still poses some difficulties ...”. In 2005, China imported more than 1.5 million cubic metres of Burmese timber worth an estimated US$350 million. Almost all of these imports were illegal; China closed the Burmese border to logs in 2006, resulting in huge inventories of logs at the border and putting many Chinese out of work (China Blocks Timber Imports From Burma [Myanmar]: www.illegal-logging.info). Ah, but then they put through highway 14 from Kunming to Mandalay. I have read, but can’t quote any stats, that illegal logging has since increased in Myanmar again, which is now nearly depleted of forest, with the logs flowing into Yunnan. So my guess is that is anyone wants to know where the missing forest land of this Canadian-Chinese forest company is, they might look towards Myanmar for the answer. And if some investors think Chinese forest companies, or Canadian ones with Chinese operations, have overstated their timber holdings, I can guess why.

My interest in this is the rare and endangered species that live in these forests. In the last couple of years, two species of gibbon have been extirpated from China and virtually all species that depend mature forest have either disappeared or are relegated to remnant “protected” forest patches where they are still hunted for meat and other products. Vietnam, Laos and Burma are huge sources of trade in illegally harvested or captured species, and are (especially Vietnam) major conduits for animals sources in other SE Asian countries, China is the main market, and Yunnan is the main port of entry. The disappearance of forests and native wildlife from Yunnan and neighbouring countries should be reason enough for anyone not to invest in companies like this.

Canada, Expo 2012, and the Republic of Korea




Barbara Yaffe (“Snubbing Expo 2012 shows Ottawa's skewed international spending priorities”, The Vancouver Sun, August 26) and similar views expressed elsewhere in the Globe and Mail make a good point, but South Korea’s Expo 2012 is not just about trade. We can learn from the Koreans. During many scientific missions there in the last decade, our hosts proudly toured their international guests through a variety of cultural and industrial gems in the country’s crown. These were not only in the big cities of Seoul and Pusan, but in towns all the way to the tip of the peninsula. On one offshore island we saw, for example, an international photography show, an international cello competition, and the two biggest shipyard in the world. Every village mayor and regional governor had something to show off that was well worth seeing; and the receptions following these events were a lesson in civic and national pride. Somehow, the Koreans manage to lead the world in arts and technology while maintaining their cultural roots: in every valley is a beautiful Buddhist temple, beside every byway a shrine, on every mountaintop a monastery. Besides being amazed and awed by the country’s arts and technology, I learned this: In the Korean national psyche is the feeling that there is nothing they cannot achieve. If they can imagine it, they believe they can do it. This is a country that, for centuries under the alternate heels of Japan’s military and China’s political hegemony, has finally thrown off the yoke of oppression and become one of the most vigorous and productive democracies in the world. Canada should recognize that, for the cost of participating in the expo, we would gain far more than an increase in trade